Shifts In Golf Course Design

March 1st, 2012

Back in the early 1900s, when the majority of our now celebrated golf courses were being designed, the development process was often a simple matter of enlisting the help of a Harry Colt or a James Braid to advise on the design before setting about the land with the help of local farmers and labourers.  It’s a credit to these gentlemen that their course layouts are still regarded as some of the finest in the world.

At the time, the concept of removing trees or using railway sleepers in bunkers was as cutting edge as capabilities allowed.  Fast forward to the present and it’s clear (and inevitable) that course design has moved on.  It’s the norm these days to push the limits, to “bury elephants” under the greens and stretch holes to previously inconceivable lengths.  While in some cases the changes have been a necessary response to advances in equipment, in others it sometimes seems the motivation is purely the architect’s ego; the spectacular over the playable, the impressive over the subtle.

Designers are given directives, and you would assume always with compromising conditions. In the early 1900’s the limitations were largely physical, whereas today the limitations are more often than not environmental, political and financial. Satisfy the golfer that wants to play the best golf courses from the Championship tees, whilst abiding by the local environmental law regarding rare species, and don’t forget to bring it all in under budget and with a sustainable future. Get anything wrong, and the course (and more specifically the designer) becomes the object of ridicule and castigation.

Starting from scratch is one thing – and most likely to fall foul of the environmentalists – but when the task at hand is renovating an existing classic, it’s the purists the designer has to worry about.  Does a critic come any tougher?  Of course, everyone is entitled to their opinions and those on golf courses will always remain subjective, but sometimes I wonder whether the criticism often levelled at the renovations, modifications, and redesigns might be a little harsh.  After all, nobody really knows what the likes of Harry Colt, James Braid and Alister MacKenzie would think of these adaptations.  Who’s to know what they would have done given the technology and opportunity available today?  Conceivably they may have been far more drastic with their thinking.
That’s not to say that we go and dig up the originals and create beasts for the modern generation.  I am certainly of the old school and whenever alterations are made to a great course, I always hope the design team are as sympathetic and subtle in their reworking as possible.  Golf, perhaps more than any other sport, allows us to retain the old, while pioneering elsewhere.  Some courses give us an almost palpable connection with our forebears which is a magical ingredient that can’t be manufactured.  Yes, teeing it up on the first of a stunning new course is exhilarating, but, to my mind at least, there’s nothing finer in the golfing world than walking the misty fairways with the ghosts of Tom Morris, Bobby Jones or Walter Hagen.  Turn over too much turf in your renovations and their footprints vanish.

But I digress – getting back to design.  Perhaps nostalgia plays a part, but I’m sure it was the limitations of the day that actually helped make the classic layouts so special and ensured they withstood the test of time.  With very little in the way of construction machinery and without consideration for the 300 yard drive, course design was a subtler, more nuanced practice that shunned the brash in favour of the balanced.  There’s much less of the obvious of which to tire.  The course continues to reveal new things to you every time you play.  Of course, course maintenance wasn’t a patch on today’s standards, which leads me to thinking that perhaps some of the plaudits have been earned accidentally.  Whatever the case, though, there’s no doubting there have been some true artists at work over the years.

All this makes me wonder what the famous designers would have done given the architectural possibilities of the twenty first century.  Would we still marvel?  Would they renovate their own originals?  And moreover, what will golf courses look like in future generations.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Golf on TV: Snitching & Spitting

February 23rd, 2012

Watching golf last weekend, two incidents left a rather unsavoury taste in my mouth. As you may have seen or read, the first taste of bile came courtesy of the disqualification of Scotland’s Peter Whiteford from the Avantha Masters.  Just one stroke off the lead, Whiteford had to endure being told on the 4th tee of the final round that he was being disqualified for an incident that happened on the final hole the day before, and in so being, he became the latest victim of TV viewers contacting the Tour to indicate a rules infraction.

Peter Whiteford won’t give a jot whether the phrase is coined as ‘Trial by Television’ or ‘TV Snitching’ but, to my mind, this is a rule that desperately needs changing.  He handled himself with great dignity and professionalism in the aftermath, but I’m sure he was inwardly cursing the snitch that denied him a shot of a first European Tour title last weekend.

And this has nothing to do with cheating or ‘getting away with it’.  Whiteford was rightly cleared of any deliberate foul play and he immediately went on record as saying that the blame lay with him – if he’d had any doubt he should’ve checked the television replay himself.  Well, technically he’s probably right, but one suspects that 99% of the golfing population felt enormous sympathy for him.

For my money, he shouldn’t have been disqualified. I understand that the rules have to be applied with rigour and the European Tour therefore had little choice, and I respect the argument that if he had any doubt at all he should’ve checked the replay before signing his card.  But let’s look at what actually happened.  Whiteford did ask his caddy and playing partner whether the ball moved, as he wasn’t sure, and they both said that they hadn’t seen it move.  Take away the cameras and that would have sufficed.  The great irony is that, despite a rule change last year following the disqualification of Padraig Harrington in similar circumstances, if Whiteford hadn’t asked his playing partner and caddy (in so doing, he demonstrated that he himself had some doubt), he wouldn’t have been disqualified.

So, no one in the group saw anything wrong and on he played, finishing and signing for a level par 72.  What Whiteford hadn’t accounted for was some busy-body TV viewers contacting the European Tour to tell them Whiteford’s ball had moved, a fact that that was upheld by the rules committee on viewing replays.  OK, you could argue that the cameras and the TV viewers were only helping to apply the rules of the game, but to my mind this is patently unfair. The only players being scrutinised are those being filmed at the moment of indiscretion – I thought sport was supposed to be played ‘on a level playing field’?  Trial by television in golf simply doesn’t allow that – it’s  the equivalent of introducing goal line technology at only one end of a football ground.

Perhaps Whiteford should’ve asked for a television replay himself, appreciating that he did have some doubt, but I think it worth bearing in mind that whilst he’s clearly a good player, he’s not currently a household name commanding attention from the television cameras every time he tees it up.  I’d bet that the concept of ‘trial by television’ is even more concerning for the likes of McIlroy and Donald, and therefore you’d imagine they are more practiced at ensuring everything gets reviewed if there is even the slightest question mark.  Whiteford did his best to play by the rules and he walked away with his dignity intact, if not as champion.

I’ve since read that the European Tour has said they ‘hope it doesn’t happen again’. Well it will, unless the rule is changed. It happened to Padraig last year (all be it at a slightly earlier stage of the tournament, although that shouldn’t make the blindest bit of difference), and it will happen again. Surely they have to introduce a rule to protect the players from armchair referees.

My big issue, however, is with the ‘jobsworth’ folk who are actually emailing in. Yes, I know that technically, you WERE correct, Whiteford should’ve incurred a penalty and having failed to do so, signing for the wrong score could only mean one thing: disqualification. You must feel very proud of yourselves. But why do you feel it your responsibility to point it out? Can you not let the traditional etiquette and official referees police the game, as they do for all the other players in the event?

I remember reading an article when John Paramor (European Tour Referee) was interviewed regarding how amateurs faired in club competitions. The crux of it was that most amateur golfers break the rules on multiple occasions over the course of the round, without even knowing it. An incorrect drop here, wrongly taken relief there, amateurs think they know the rules better than they really do. Unless you’re John Paramor, it’s practically impossible to maintain an encyclopaedic knowledge of the rules of golf, so you can pretty much guarantee that these same people who call and email in, are guilty of breaking the rules themselves.  I don’t suppose they would enjoy their golf very much if they were “DQ’d” every week, and even less so if it came courtesy of an over-zealous dog walker or greenkeeper dashing up to the clubhouse to report an infringement of Rule 18-2(a). Maybe the ‘armchair referees’ should bear this in mind next time they feel impelled to email their observations.

So, all this ruined one man’s chances of winning and the enjoyment of hundreds of thousands of fans.  Which brings me to my second bitter aftertaste, and something which would also have spoiled the enjoyment for legions of fans, many of whom did complain (and with some justification).  This time, of course, nothing was done about it.

Slow play (also a rules infringement) is painful enough, but accompany it with endless spitting and it becomes unwatchable.  Keegan Bradley was the guilty party over in the US, though he isn’t alone amongst the top American golfers, Tiger being one of them.  Admittedly, spitting isn’t as reviled in the US as it is here and Bradley, to his credit, has since apologised and made a conscious effort to refrain from doing so.  (More than can be said for Tiger).  But my point is simply that, when it comes to overwhelming public opinion, justice wasn’t meted out very satisfactorily this weekend.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

The Big Thaw

February 16th, 2012

Guest Author: Chris Lomas, Secretary at Worplesdon Golf Club

Patience is the Key…

Winter golf and especially golf courses in the winter, have evolved over the last 20 years. Turf quality in the close season has improved immeasurably, as has the clothing which allows us to play in the most inclement weather. We are therefore playing a lot more golf, throughout the winter months, than we have ever done before. Expectations have also increased and whilst most people will tolerate a slight drop in turf quality and green speed, they still expect the courses they play to be in decent condition.

For this reason we must be tolerant when the snow begins to melt and/or the frozen grounds begins to thaw. This is when serious and long term damage can be done. More often than not, when the thaw is underway, the days can be mild and the sun can be shining. The snow has disappeared from the golfers gardens and this is where the problems often start. I know from experience that General Managers/Secretaries start to come under pressure from members to open the course and it can also be difficult to continually turn away important revenue, especially when the course looks not just playable but tempting from the clubhouse. However patience is vital and we must all respect the judgment of the Course Manager and here is why….

Without wishing to teach anyone to suck eggs, the thaw starts from the top. The frost can often penetrate the ground many inches down. When the snow starts to melt, apart from natural run off, the water has nowhere to run. In cannot permeate through the ground as it would normally as it is sat on a number of inches of frost. Even if there has not been any snow, the ground only freezes because of it’s moisture content. Therefore when the ground starts to thaw, the water just sits on the top, saturating the surfaces. Walking on such surfaces alone can be very damaging and the damage done can take months to repair. However, the real damage at this time is root break, especially on the fine turf areas such as the greens and tees. When the surface is soft and below is frozen, walking on the turf will break the roots and likely kill the plant. Multiply this with hundreds of footprints over a relatively small area and without exaggerating you can devastate your greens. Once again speaking from experience, this can take until well into to June to fully repair and all of a sudden you regret caving in to the desires of the golfers. Certainly there is not a golfer I know, who would still push to play once they are aware of the consequences if their actions.

So even if the weather is mild, your garden is clear and the course is looking very inviting, please try to respect the decision made by your Course Manager. Even if you think he is being over cautious, a few lost days of golf now can help prevent poor greens for months to come.

Chris Lomas is the Secretary of Worplesdon Golf Club. For 11 years prior to that he was Course Manager of The Berkshire Golf Club and prior to that was Deputy Head Greenkeeper at Swinley Forest Golf Club. You can read his blog articles by clicking on this link here.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Tralee GC Course Review

February 8th, 2012

Whenever I’m visiting a club I’ve not been to before, especially an old one, I enjoy strolling around the clubhouse and just soaking up the atmosphere. I like the welcome area displays that show off a club’s history, with a few record scorecards and famous club trophies, with the odd coincidence or impressive feat recorded for posterity. For me, it all adds to the experience you savour as a visitor. My first few minutes at Tralee GC were spent doing just this, but while there was plenty to indulge my golfing curiosity, it was the television screen scrolling through breathtaking panoramas of the golf course that really got me itching to tee it up.

To describe the course as photogenic would be a gross understatement. Here you can stand atop mountainous dunes and look out across Banna Strand to the Atlantic Ocean, and let your eyes roam over the undulating fairways and trace the spectacular holes that meander through the natural links land. Perhaps it helped that I caught Tralee on a gorgeous late summer afternoon, but it’s no exaggeration to say that the course afforded the best views I’ve ever witnessed on a golf course. I’ll concede that for nostalgia it’s tough to beat playing the last few holes towards the town at St. Andrews, but for sheer spectacular scenery, I don’t think anything I’ve seen comes close to Tralee.

As for the Arnold Palmer designed course, it lived up to expectations, and then some. While the back nine is rightly famed for its rugged beauty and breathtaking holes, I was already smitten by then, wooed by some superb holes on the outward nine. The reputation of the back nine (so good is it that Palmer was memorably quoted as saying: “I may have designed the first nine, but surely God designed the back nine”) has somewhat overshadowed the jewels on the front. In their own right they are good enough that, picked up and dropped anywhere else in the world, they’d by renowned as a world-class stretch of links in their own right. They only thing they suffer is proximity to an even better nine holes. And you’ll always get to those, so don’t be in too much of a hurry and just appreciate the quality of the outward loop in its own right.

It’s easy to see why Tralee sits comfortably amongst the best courses in Europe, if not the world. Quite simply, if you’re in the western half of Ireland, you have to play it.

Front Nine

The course impresses quickly at Tralee, with the par four 1st demanding you work hard for a par, though it can still fairly be described as a ‘gentle’ opener. Reaching the green, a glance back towards the clubhouse allows you to appreciate the change in elevation from your approach shot to the green.

If evidence were needed that the front nine at Tralee is going to offer something very special, you don’t have to wait long. The par 5 second is a spectacular, sweeping coast-hugger that requires shots into three different wind directions, each one demanding precision and concentration – not easy given the first grand view of the rugged Atlantic coastline.

The 3rd is considered the signature hole at Tralee, a nervy par three played in close proximity to the crashing waves, with the green sited just in front of a 14th Century Castle. Not one for the faint-hearted, it’s the first of many fabulous par threes.

Holes four and five flank each other, with mirrored elevation changes and doglegs. Be careful to avoid the old stone wall running alongside the fourth fairway, though, or it’ll claim your errant ball as another victim.

The sixth hole, with its sharp dogleg, guarantees an approach from the rough (depending on how much of the corner you chew) or from the humps and hollows in a fairway that resemble moguls on a ski run. It’s classic links golf, plus it offers an opportunity of a ‘risk and reward’ tee shot. I’m sure a four is an underrated score here.

With Tralee being a loop of two nines, the par three 7th turns the corner back towards the clubhouse. Between this and the birdie opportunity on the uphill par five 9th, is the cracking par four 8th that doglegs left whilst hugging the rugged coastline. Steep dunes and a shapely fairway frame this hole perfectly, and demand prudent course management in order to earn a score. It was certainly one of my favourite holes on the course, and I’d imagine it plays as one of the toughest. Presuming you’ve earned that birdie on the 9th, a quick stop in the halfway hut should recharge you for the remaining holes.

Back Nine

The par four 10th doglegs left down towards the dunes, and I’d advise against carving your drive into the adjacent field as it’s not easy from there, trust me. Still, it’s another solid par four, and you catch a glance at the lengthy par five 11th to come. There’s a premium on accuracy here as you ascend towards the highest point of the course. It’s another scoring opportunity for sure, but even if you don’t walk off with a birdie, the view from here is reward in itself.

The 12th hole for me was the best on the course. I loved it. Not least for the chance granted on the hole before to witness the groups in front attempting to traverse the incredibly testing second shot over the daunting ravine, so you’re fully aware of what’s to come. The drive is hard enough – it’s fairly obvious where to go, but it’s a semi-blind shot. Having managed to get this away, I thought I’d be left with a fairly straightforward short or medium iron to the putting surface, but was somewhat dismayed to find I actually had a huge carry that was going to test my abilities from a hanging lie with a fairway wood. No bail out area (unless you count a ‘lay-up’ pitch down the fairway – and let’s face it, I didn’t come to Tralee to protect my scorecard by playing ‘pat-a-cake’ golf), just the requirement to produce a Hollywood golf shot on demand. Whatever your resulting score, it’s a very special golf hole.

From there, the par three 13th is equally spectacular, a short iron to a narrow target with punishment surrounding the green on all sides. It’s at this point that you wonder how the course can get any better, but the final loop of holes continues to impress.

The 14th and 15th are two picturesque par four’s that seem to be play in relative calmness (perhaps due to their location near a small inlet), the latter requiring a careful tee shot played to a plateaux fairway and a controlled approach to a well guarded green.

The course then crescendos in elevation, drama, and quality of view over the par three 16th and par four 17th. Two world-class holes and two more candidates for my favourite on the course. The gentle par five 18th offers another good birdie chance, and is a fitting end to the most fantastic round of golf.

The most fitting end to the day however, is found upstairs in Tralee’s Golf Club Bar where the glass panelled clubhouse affords continued enjoyment of the golfing scenery. The food is great, as are the very welcoming members. Get a pint of Guinness and relive the day with your playing partners.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Racing to Predict Tiger’s Comback

February 2nd, 2012

So Tiger’s back. Or he isn’t. It all depends on your point of view.  One thing that is certainly back is the mountain of monotonous articles written on his every move, shot, thought, and interview. There seems to be a ramification, permutation, rhyme and reason for everything he does.  Forgive me a moment but… yawn.

I’d love to see Tiger back to his best, with subsequent articles lavishing praise on him for sensational victories, dominating performances, and impossible shots under pressure. But can we not save the headlines and questions until he produces just that?

You can’t help but feel that journalists believe there will be a certain amount of kudos bestowed upon them for being the first to rightly predict the dawn of the new Tiger era. Alright, I accept that they’re just doing their job and reporting on items that engage the readers, but it gets a bit ridiculous when he holes a putt and a commentator announces “I think you can safely say Tiger is back”. Crikey, I wish it was that easy for the rest of us. And isn’t it a little disrespectful to guys like Robert Rock that all the articles after this last weekend focused on the ‘nearly’ performance of Tiger rather than the ex-club pro who started the day level with the great Tiger Woods and beat him?

So he’s on the comeback trail, fine, but at the moment, that’s all you can say. A few years back, we were questioning why the best English players couldn’t get past the winning post in front of Woods. Now we have guys that do, but instead of focusing our attention on them, the trend is to question Tiger’s inadequacies.

Robert Rock is a prime example of how I believe golf has changed over the last ten years. A question was put to him on Saturday regarding his feelings on playing with Woods on Sunday, given that back in 2003 he was teaching golf and selling Mars bars, whilst Woods had won countless Majors and was dominating the sport. The answer, “It’s pretty cool’, was hardly insightful, but his performance on Sunday did all the talking. Ten years ago, most players would have done what the golfing media was expecting Rock to do and crumble under the pressure. Admittedly, a lot has happened in Woods’ career since those heydays, but he still has an aura. The difference is that ten years ago, when Rock, McIlroy, and the younger breed were still playing with a half set and from the ladies tees in a Junior Medal (or selling Mars bars), they were learning that in order to beat him, you had to raise the bar. It’s been the same in other sports, too. Just think of the impact Roger Federer has had on tennis. I’m sure Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic would be the first to tell you they wouldn’t be the players they are if they hadn’t had to set out to beat him.

In Tiger’s pomp, players hoped to get near to his level, but were resigned to losing once he had the lead. Now, players know they have to surpass the levels he set. I’m not suggesting Robert Rock is now a better player than Woods, but I think there is enough evidence over recent years to suggest that players know what levels they have to achieve in order to win. Previous statements such as “if Tiger plays well, we’re playing for second”, and “Tiger will win two majors per year, that only leaves two for the rest of us” are no longer valid. Tiger can play well and expect this generation to go toe-to-toe with him, regardless of how his supposed comeback is developing. Some even catch him on the last day now (Graeme MacDowell at the Chevron in 2010). That just didn’t happen before. Majors are won by guys who go out and seize their opportunity (Y.E.Yang beating Tiger at the PGA Championship), rather than by guys hoping Tiger’s game doesn’t show up.

Wood’s is certainly on his way back, but if he does get back to his best, the difference is that this time players aren’t scared to take him on. I’m sure he’ll have many victories in the future, including Majors, battling ones, and comfortable ones, but this generation will also inflict more defeats.

So there it is, an article complaining about the reams of paper wasted on Tiger in which I’ve managed to squeeze in 18 references to him.  Ah well, it’s an easy trap to fall in to.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Deer Oh Deer!

January 26th, 2012

I have a confession. It’s been niggling my mind for a couple of years. I wish I could say we’ve all done it, but I doubt it very much.   This all relates to an incident involving me, a wedge, and one of the Queen’s animals.  You can see where this is going.  Well, it’s not a moment I’m particularly proud of, but it’s time I got it off my chest.

When I lived in Twickenham, I was a member of Hampton Court Palace Golf Club, which is set within beautiful Bushy Park in South West London. The course offers one of the most enjoyable environments in which to play golf near the city, with expansive, unspoiled parkland in every direction.  Not only that, but it’s home to hundreds (if not thousands, I don’t know which) of deer. They really are part of the furniture, and it surprises almost everyone who first steps foot on the course just how close they get to you. Appropriately, local rules at the club give the deer right of way, and while the odd frustrating break might negatively affect the scorecard (think hoof marks in the bunkers, teeth marks on your ball), it doesn’t detract from the experience of playing. Indeed, you’d argue that the deer make it even more special.

If you’ve ever played at Hampton Court Palace, you’ll know that at some point in your round you’ll be faced with the shot that, if you get it wrong, could lead to an anxious ‘heart in mouth’ moment as your ball careers towards a herd of deer.  There’s no denying that these noble creatures know very well that they have priority, and our interminable pursuit of a getting a small white ball into 18 little cups buried in the ground isn’t going to get between them and the luscious fairways that supply lunch.

The deer are so numerous that if everyone stopped and waited for every single one to be out of range prior to playing their shot, rounds at Hampton Court Palace would take days rather than hours.  As such, one of the conditions of play is that if you hit a deer, you should report it to the club immediately so that the animal can be checked over. If people are responsible about this, I’m sure casualties are kept to a minimum. (I am not enjoying reliving this).

So, one sunny summer’s day a couple of years ago, I was strolling down the second fairway contemplating the 100 yard shot to the green that lay ahead. To paint a picture briefly, the pin was right at the back of the green and a lonesome deer was nonchalantly nibbling away contently about 10 yards in front of the green. Typically the deer (we’ll call him ‘Derek’) was smack bang on a line between my ball and said target. Stating my defence (and I’ll concede at this point that it’s a fairly weak defence), I’d like to highlight that I did my utmost to move Derek along. I walked up as close as I dared in the hope he’d get scared and walk off. I clapped my hands loudly to frighten him off. I think I even ‘schewed’ him at one point, though I’m keen to stress that’s ‘schew’ not ‘shoe’… that really would bring on a court case. But nothing, Derek wasn’t going anywhere.

I suppose I have to own up to the fact that at this point in my golfing career I was a professional golfer regularly playing on satellite tours, booked in for Tour School, and generally backing my own abilities. This all taken into account, an obstacle (Derek) at 80yards for a pro playing a 100yard wedge shot, shouldn’t really come into the equation. And with that professional arrogance, I went about my business as per usual and made a positive swing at the golf ball.

There are certain moments in life where everything seems to happen in slow motion. As if time slows, allowing you to draw out every tiny detail because you know the impending psychological pain is going to scar your mind and haunt you forever. This was one such moment. That very instant that my club head made contact with the ball, before even looking up I knew there was only one place this Titleist was heading. The contact was poor; I’d made the most dribbling attempt at a golf swing. It had poor Derek’s name written all over it. The only question was where it was going to hit him.

Sadly and all too literally, the answer was ‘right between the eyes’. I guess it would be unfair to say ‘he never saw it coming’, but he really didn’t. For the entire time that ball was in the air, my hand was covering my open mouth. I was about to kill one of the Queen’s beloved animals. What was the punishment for such treason? Could you still be sent to the Tower? I saw flashes of future tabloid headlines tarnishing my character, my golfing name would be mud.

And the noise, oh, the noise was horrific. Have you ever heard a golf ball strike a skull?  You don’t want to.  I fully expected poor Derek’s lights to go out permanently. Surely he’d just lean over and crash to the floor, leaving me with an awful lot of explaining to do. But remarkably (and very thankfully) he didn’t.  Alright, he leapt five feet in the air like you’d expect, but his only other reaction was to skip off to the side of the fairway, shake his head a little, and then go back to the day job of chewing the grass. I guess the rutting season gives you a greater headache than a golf ball – they’re a hard breed these deer.

I waited around for a delayed reaction but that never came either. Derek was fine, and had even had the grace to help my ball to within 10 feet of the hole. It was only right that I should miss the putt, though I like to put it down to the emotional turmoil I was going through at the time.  Far as I could tell, the only lasting legacy was my guilt.

But my confession, I guess, is two-fold.  I also apologise unreservedly for besmirching the term “professional golfer”.  If you can’t hit a wedge shot with a 20% margin of error, what does that say about you and your right to professional status?  There, I said it. From this day forward I can walk the fairways safe in the knowledge that my wedge inadequacies are off my chest.

You’ll be relieved to know that Derek really was fine. He may have walked off in a diagonal line with an egg shaped lump on his temple, he was well enough to go back to chomping contentedly away in a matter of moments.

The Queen doesn’t know, by the way, so I’d appreciate it if you kept this between us.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

In Search of the Portuguese Star

January 19th, 2012

Germany had its Bernhard Langer, and more recently, Martin Kaymer.  Spain had, of course, the inimitable Seve, then Jose Maria Olazabal and Sergio Garcia.  Sweden has been a conveyor-belt of Ryder Cup players, Denmark has Thomas Bjorn and even Italy, with its comparatively modest golfing pedigree, has had Costantino Rocca, and now the Molinari brothers and Matteo Mannassero.  France has perhaps underachieved, but has still delivered a list of established European Tour Pros and names that we all know, like Jean Van de Veld.  Northern Ireland punches well above its weight, boasting three Major champions in little over a year, Wales brought us Ian Woosnam and Scotland a catalogue of famous old names plus some more recent Major winners in Sandy Lyle and Paul Lawrie. While England hasn’t produced a Major winner since Nick Faldo, there has been a constant stream of world class professionals, including recent World Number Ones Lee Westwood and Luke Donald.  But for all the famous golfers making a name for both themselves and their respective European countries, Portugal remains conspicuous in its absence.

Despite an abundance of top notch golfing facilities across the Algarve and beyond, many of which have been established for decades, Portugal is still awaiting their first golfing superstar.  It’s a shame, and the region would benefit from a breakthrough performance. Surely it’s time the trend was bucked.

It’s only recently that Ricardo Santos was appointed brand ambassador for Oceanico, but in the past few years it’s been the faces of Lee Westwood and Darren Clarke acting as the inspiration to a Portuguese nation of golfers. Then again, perhaps that’s half the point. Perhaps they aren’t intended to provide inspiration to the Portuguese, but inspiration to British tourists. That’s all well and good, but for the sake of home grown talent in Portugal, they need their own superstar. Longer term, a home grown player will serve as much greater influence on the growth of their domestic game, and in turn the success of the resorts, than borrowing a pro from another part of the world.  By all accounts, Seve almost single-handedly brought golf to the domestic Spanish market.  What Portugal would do for the same.

Professional golfers undeniably bring exposure to their native countries on the golfing map. Consider the number of Americans now likely to add the rugged links courses of Northern Ireland to their itineraries when visiting Ireland, just to experience the course where Darren, Rory and GMac grew up. Without doubt, a Major champion from Portugal would widen the country’s golfing reach, especially if the Major they won was a US Masters or US Open.

Of course, there are plenty of reasons that will have contributed to Portugal’s failure to-date, but surely over the years one player should’ve made it through to the big time? Granted, there have been one or two flirting with the fringes of the European Tour for a few years, but are any of them considered to be a ‘household name’?

For a start, the trouble for Portugal is that there hasn’t been someone from a previous era of such stature as Gary Player or Seve Ballesteros, to raise the profile of golf to the youngsters. In most successful golfing countries, one player in a generation inspired a future pool of talent. Years later, one of these inspired another group of youngsters. The trouble is, you need that initial breakthrough to kick start the process, and to date Portugal hasn’t had one. Sadly for golf, one suspects that the inspiration was concentrated in other sports, particularly football, from the likes of Eusebio, Figo and Cristiano Ronaldo. Football is undoubtedly ‘cooler’ than golf, and you’d suspect that the younger generation dream of emulating Ronaldo’s footsteps, rather than Jose-Filipe Lima. No disrespect intended.

I also doubt that the infrastructure and support levels at the top of the amateur circuit in Portugal rival that of other countries. For example, can it compare to the EGU who do a sterling job in fostering the best young talent to the professional ranks? Does the Portuguese golf federation do the job to the same effect? Or produce similar results? Clearly not, though funding and volumes of players are surely valid excuses.

As touched on, financial reasons are perhaps the greatest hindrance of all. Portugal’s economic situation is well documented, so it’s probably fair to assume that in an industry priced towards tourists, the average Portuguese family might well be unable to afford, let alone justify, a sizeable outlay at the local golf club.

I’m sure there are many other contributing factors, too, and doubtless there are people far better placed to explain them.  But the roots of the problem are certainly there to see.

Of course, one day a Portuguese player will break through and buck the trend and the lift it will give to the region, and in particular the domestic game, when it does will be immense. While the 2018 Ryder Cup was recently awarded to France, there was a very strong case for Portugal to host the event. It’s fair to assume that they will bid again (and get it) another year, but you have to wonder whether the weight of a star player behind a bid might make the difference.  That the first Ryder Cup in Continental Europe went to Valderrama in Spain was solely down to Seve’s captivating heroics in the event during the 1980s and early 1990s. Perhaps when it comes to bidding for the 2022 Ryder Cup, Portugal may have a superstar to do just that. A famous ambassador carries significant weight to a Ryder Cup bid, and a Ryder Cup elevates a country beyond all recognition in golfing terms.

Consider the boost French golf will be given for the coming years as it prepares for the arrival of the Ryder Cup at Le Golf National. Golf will go wild as 2018 gets closer, and France stands to benefit. Nobody is saying that hosting a Ryder Cup is the only route to longevity of success, but you can see how Portugal would benefit from doing so in the future. A home grown Major Champion would undoubtedly influence a bid, and greatly raise the profile of the country as a golfing destination on the world stage.

Sadly, as things stand, that doesn’t look particularly likely, but regardless I hope Portugal produces at least one stand-out player sooner than 2022. The courses, facilities, and weather are too good a breeding ground for the barrenness to continue.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Links On Show

January 12th, 2012

If you were still indulging in festive leftovers you might well have missed the start to the European and PGA 2012 Tours, both of which got underway last week. Yes quite, it was a fairly inconspicuous start, so you are of course excused. With the post-season competitions and money-spinners, the professional golfing merry-go-round doesn’t seem to stop.

Unless you are one of the Rookie’s on tour, you’d probably have to concede that The Africa Open and the Hyundai Tournament of Champions are a pair of fairly uninspiring season openers.  I don’t mean this as a criticism of the respective tours, as we all understand that the flagship events tend to be scheduled mid-season, but it got me thinking….which event really kick starts the public’s interest in the new season?

For the majority (that is, the averagely keen golfer and those without Sky TV) interest is usually ignited by The Masters.  For more hardened enthusiasts, the Dubai Desert Classic, the World Matchplay or the Phoenix Open are often the first events that have us tuning in.  All of these are great events in their own right, but it’s not rocket science to spot the correlation between level of interest and number of world class players in the starting field.

Personally, I’ll be keeping a close eye on all of these, and perhaps an earlier eye on the Volvo Golf Champions event at The Links at Fancourt. This one is purely down to the fact I’ve played the course a few times and it’s one of my favourites. There’s always extra interest when you’ve played the golf course (one of the special attractions golf has over so many other sports).  It’s even better still when you have enjoyed the odd birdie, and affords us to the right to heckle the professional efforts to ‘only score a par’!  And, naturally, the conditions they’re playing in are identical to (if not easier than) when you played – that cauldron pressure, off the very back tees…. and everyone’s allowed a mulligan, right?  OK, perhaps not, but it’s nice to let yourself dream.

Still, even watching all of these early season events as the players build their form, nothing inspires us to dust off the clubs and go out there and play ourselves more than the sight of rhododendrons in bloom and Magnolia Lane as The Masters rolls around.  However, this year there is a stretch of tournaments that I’m looking forward to more than any others in recent years. And bear in mind it’s a bumper year, what with the Ryder Cup upon us again in September.

The most intriguing and appealing run of events for me start at the end of June due to the recent announcement that The Irish Open will be contested at Royal Portrush. This means there is now a run of four weeks that will see three links courses, one Major Championship, one future Ryder Cup venue, and one litmus test for a future Open Championship venue.

The Irish Open (Royal Portrush), Scottish Open (Castle Stuart), and The Open (Royal Lytham & St. Anne’s) promise to be superb, and it is here that will provide a rarity to savour – being able to witness three links courses in use for professional events in such quick succession. Usually, we’re confined to one a year. I only hope that some of the top name players use the first two as a warm up for The Open. After all, and as demonstrated with a few of the early season examples above, a good quality field is essential for raising the public interest. You’d think that 2012 (being a Ryder Cup year) won’t struggle for interest, and with this being prime time for the jostling of ranking points, the fields are likely to be top notch. It’s a given that McIlroy, Clarke, Harrington, and McDowell will play at Portrush, and with many big names opting for the links of Castle Stuart last year in preparation for The Open, you’d think that many will do the same again. There is something extra provided by the vagaries of a good links course, but sadly it’s increasingly a lost art in the professional game. If it wasn’t for The Open, you wonder whether there would be any on display.  I know it’s all about access, finances, and galleries but it’s still a shame.

Either way, these four weeks from 28th June – 22nd July look set to provide the season highlight, perhaps with the exception of the Ryder Cup under Jose Maria Olazabal’s stewardship at Medinah in September . The struggle will be to draw oneself away from the armchair and onto the golf course.  I can sense a few sneaky evening rounds ahead.

I’d be interested to know which events you’re most looking forward to. There are the obvious and usual candidates, and let’s not forget the Curtis Cup at The Nairn Golf Club, or some of the major amateur events that often provide a fascinating insight into the next generation of players. Perhaps it’s this run of links courses that tick your boxes, too. I’d be interested to hear your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Christmas Quiz Answers

January 4th, 2012

Ed is currently on paternity leave but will be writing again very soon. With this in mind, the blog is very short this week – just the answers to the Christmas Quiz. Hopefully it provided some entertainment over the festive period, and I trust you’ve got them all worked out. You may have noticed one small error – that of ‘No. 3’ where there are only 4 events in the Fed Ex Cup post season, rather than 5. Apologies if it had you stumped for days!

 

  1. 31 t at the W C of G = 31 teams at the World Cup of Golf
  2. 12 p in a R C t = 12 players in a Ryder Cup team
  3. 5 e in the FE C P S = 5 events in the Fed Ex Cup Post Season
  4. 1934 f M T = 1934 first Masters Tournament
  5. 2 s d = a d b = 2 shots dropped = a double bogey
  6. 4 M in a y = 4 Majors in a Year
  7. 80 is the a of P A = 80 is the age of Peter Alliss
  8. 156 p in the f for the O C = 156 players in the field for the Open Championship
  9. 5 in the O W G R is A S = 5 in the Official World Golf Rankings is Adam Scott
  10. 46 e on the R to D = 46 events on the Race to Dubai
  11. 14 c in the b = 14 clubs in the bag
  12. 35 i in a s l p = 35 Inches in a standard length putter
  13. 112 b on the O C at S A = 112 bunkers on the Old Course at St.Andrews
  14. 2005 M C w the U S O = 2005 Michael Campbell won the US Open
  15. 15 p s by the E S C t = 15 points scored by the European Solheim Cup Team
  16. 30 E T C at Q S = 30 European Tour Cards at Qualifying School
  17. 73 PGA T v for J N = 73 PGA Tour victories for Jack Nicklaus
  18. 2013 T O C at M = 2013 The Open Championship at Muirfield
  19. 22 is the a of R M = 22 is the age of Rory McIlroy
  20. 46 d of l on a n i = 46 degrees of loft on a nine iron
  21. 3 u p  = an a = 3 under par = an albatross
  22. 2011 first M w with a b p = 2011 first Major won with a belly putter
  23. 8 O of M T w by C M = 8 Order of Merits Titles won by Colin Montgomerie
  24. 14 p s by the G B & I W C T = 14 points scored by the Great Britain & Ireland Walker Cup Team
  25. 4 M w by P M = 4 Majors won by Phil Mickelson
  26. 2018 R C at L G N = 2018 Ryder Cup at Le Golf National
  27. 1995 y J D w t O C = 1995 year John Daly won the Open Championship
  28. 1 p s for o o b = 1 penalty stroke for out of bounds
  29. 141 O C at R L & S A = 141st Open Championship at Royal Lytham & St. Annes
  30. 6 M in N F’s c = 6 Majors in Nick Faldo’s Career

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

iSpyGolf Christmas Quiz

December 22nd, 2011


A Yule time quiz seems an appropriate interlude to the normal blog. Quite simply, see if you can find the solutions for the number and letter combinations below. You may well have seen a similar style puzzle before – the variation here being that all of the solutions are linked to golf.  As an example, the answer to ‘18 h on a g c ’ would be ‘18 holes on a golf course’ and names and proper nouns are in capitals. Simple!  Good luck, answers next time…

 

  1. 31 t at the W C of G
  2. 12 p in a R C t
  3. 5 e in the FE C P S
  4. 1934 f M T
  5. 2 s d = a d b
  6. 4 M in a y
  7. 80 is the a of P A
  8. 156 p in the f for the O C
  9. 5 in the O W G R is A S
  10. 46 e on the R to D
  11. 14 c in the b
  12. 35 i in a s l p
  13. 112 b on the O C at S A
  14. 2005 M C w the U S O
  15. 15 p s by the E S C t
  16. 30 E T C at Q S
  17. 73 PGA T v for J N
  18. 2013 T O C at M
  19. 22 is the a of R M
  20. 46 d of l on a n i
  21. 3 u p  = an a
  22. 2011 first M w with a b p
  23. 8 O of M T w by C M
  24. 14 p s by the G B & I W C T
  25. 4 M w by P M
  26. 2018 R C at L G N
  27. 1995 y J D w t O C
  28. 1 p s for o o b
  29. 141 O C at R L & S A
  30. 6 M in N F’s c

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.